ABS Plastic vs. Nylon: A Detailed 3D Printing Material Comparison

Introduction: The Importance of Material Selection in 3D Printing

In the field of 3D printing, material selection plays a pivotal role in determining not only a product’s aesthetic quality, but also its functionality and durability. Different materials across the spectrum from ABS plastic to nylon offer unique advantages based on their distinct properties.

  • ABS Plastic: Known for its robust strength and high-temperature resistance making it an excellent choice for components that need to withstand wear and tear.
  • Nylon: Renowned for its versatility with superior flexibility, impact resistance and longevity qualities, ideal for intricate designs.

Choosing the right material, therefore, necessitates careful analysis and understanding of the technical principles underlying each type, taking into consideration aspects such as heat tolerance, tensile strength, or flexibility depending on the design requirements at hand.

Basics of ABS Plastic and Nylon

In 3D printing, a common material utilized is Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene or ABS plastic. Known for its high melting point and ability to withstand stress, ABS has robust physical properties making it particularly popular in the production of objects that require durability such as toys, like Lego bricks. Its strong, slightly flexible nature coupled with its capacity to maintain detail makes it ideal for both professionals and hobbyists alike.

  • Definition: ABS, known chemically as acrylonitrile butadiene styrene, is an opaque engineering thermoplastic widely used in digital manufacturing processes due to its resistance to impact and heat.
  • Properties: It boasts tensile strength and is highly resistant to physical impacts and various types of chemical corrosion allowing for a long-lasting finished product.
  • Common Uses in 3D Printing: Due to its toughness and resilience to significant wear and tear, it’s commonly used in applications like prototyping, tooling, and producing end-use parts.

Moving on to nylon- This versatile material distinguished by its exceptional strength, flexibility, and durability, finds extensive use in 3D printing. Similar to ABS, Nylon exhibits good thermal properties and also possesses remarkable surface hardness and low friction coefficients which make it suitable for moving components.

  • Definition: Commonly referred to as Polyamide (PA), nylon is a synthetic polymer characterized by its versatility.
  • Characteristics: While maintaining excellent mechanical properties such as stiffness and abrasion resistance under wide temperature ranges, Nylon exhibits excellent fatigue resistance even after repeated bending thanks to its elasticity property.
  • Typical Use Cases in 3D Printing: Given its excellent strength-to-weight ratio and impact resistance, it’s typically used in automotive components, consumer products, and industrial equipment.

Detailed Comparison of ABS Plastic and Nylon in 3D Printing

When it comes to 3D printing, the choice of material significantly impacts the final product’s properties. ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) and Nylon are two popular materials, each with its unique set of characteristics. This detailed comparison aims to highlight the differences between ABS and Nylon, focusing on their physical properties, printing requirements, and typical applications. For those looking to explore 3D printing services, 3D Printing Services offer a range of options for both materials.

Physical Properties

Property ABS Nylon
Flexibility Less flexible than Nylon More flexible
Strength High impact resistance Higher tensile strength
Heat Resistance Good Excellent
Chemical Resistance Strong Stronger than ABS

Printing Requirements

  • ABS: Requires a heated bed to prevent warping, curling, and cracking. It is also noted for releasing particles during printing, necessitating a well-ventilated area or a printer with a closed enclosure.
  • Nylon: Demands precise temperature control to avoid melting and absorbs moisture, which can affect print quality. Pre-drying Nylon filament is often recommended.

Typical Applications

ABS is widely used for prints that need to be durable, strong, and heat resistant, making it ideal for technical applications and moving parts. On the other hand, Nylon’s superior strength, flexibility, and resistance to wear and tear make it suitable for functional parts that require these properties, such as gears and hinges.

In conclusion, both ABS and Nylon offer distinct advantages for 3D printing, with the choice between them depending on the specific requirements of the print job. Understanding these differences is crucial for selecting the right material to achieve the desired outcome in 3D printing projects.

Application-Based Suitability of ABS Plastic and Nylon in 3D Printing

The choice between ABS plastic and nylon for a 3D printing project often comes down to the distinct attributes each material brings to the table, which make them more suitable for specific applications. For instance, ABS plastic holds better dimensional stability, which makes it perfect when intricate details are required or when creating objects with interlocking parts. It also boasts advantageous properties such as easy sanding and painting, making it ideal for automotive components, phone cases, and other display products.

  • High-temperature resistance: ABS’s ability to withstand higher temperatures without deforming makes it an excellent choice for items likely to be exposed to heat.
  • Durability: ABS’s toughness and impact resistance make it perfect for manufacturing robust, long-lasting goods like protective headgear.

On the other hand, due to its exceptional strength and flexibility, nylon might be favoured for applications that require durability and energy absorption, such as mechanical parts, gears, or snap fits.

  • Flexibility : Nylon’s admirable elasticity makes it ideal for flexible hinges and wearable devices.
  • Chemical Resistance: If your printed object is going to come into contact with chemicals, opting for nylon would be beneficial due to its superior chemical resistance.

Post Production Considerations for ABS Plastic and Nylon Prints

The post-production phase of 3D printing closely considers the finishing and smoothing options available for both ABS plastic prints and nylon prints. For ABS plastic, which is popularly known for being easy to sand and smooth, several methods are applied such as chemical smoothing using a fog of acetone vapor that polishes its surface without losing intricate details. Moreover, vigorous techniques can be used including the application of epoxy coatings or filler primers, filing, grinding, as well as direct engine turning.

  • Finishing ABS Plastic: Following an up-close inspection to identify rough patches liberally applying an adhesive in order to fill those areas, after drying it’s sanded off leaving behind a marking compound at low spots. This process, conducted repeatedly until satisfaction, leads to a refined finished product.

  • Nylon Finishing Process: On the other hand, nylon printed parts can undergo dyed finishes, making them more versatile in terms of appearance. It’s worth noting that nylon exhibits relative resistance to standard smoothing processes because of its robustness—some users have found that sealing nylon filaments with thin CA glue before sanding can provide some form of efficiency during this part of the procedure. Therefore, treatment with specific substances may enhance the durability of items made from this material. As expected, each method has distinct considerations, leading to different final visual effects and levels of detail retention.

Cost Analysis: ABS Plastic vs. Nylon in 3D Printing

In terms of cost analysis, the use of Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS) plastic and Nylon as materials for 3D printing can greatly affect expenses due to their varying characteristics. Typically, ABS is considered as a more budget-friendly material.

  • ABS Plastic: When utilized in 3D printing, ABS generally necessitates fewer overhead costs. The general cost categories associated with its usage primarily include the purchase price, maintenance for the printer, specifically temperature regulation elements considering that ABS requires a high extrusion temperature, and potential waste management fees given the non-biodegradable nature of ABS.
  • Nylon: On the other hand, choosing Nylon could result in higher expenditures. Its material cost is typically greater than ABS due to its superior durability and flexibility. Moreover, it often demands specialized hardware upgrades or specific 3D printers equipped to handle Nylon’s print prerequisites such as increased heat resistance and containment. Plus, post-printing treatments like dyeing adds extra expense.

Overall, while ABS may lead to lower upfront costs friendly for beginners, careful cost benefit analysis should be conducted as long-term sustainability considerations or complex project requirements might favor using Nylon despite the initial cost increase.

Environmental Impact: Eco-Friendliness of ABS Plastic vs Nylon in 3D Printing – An Analysis

In the realm of 3D printing, both ABS plastic and nylon have environmental implications that should be taken into account. Broadly speaking, ABS plastic is less eco-friendly due to its petroleum basis; it also emits toxic fumes when melted during the printing process which can impact indoor air quality.

  • Nylon tends to fare better on the eco-friendliness scale – made from plant-based materials, it’s generally considered a more sustainable choice. Plus, fewer harmful emissions are produced during the melting point stage. Despite being more eco-friendly, one downside of using nylon is that it absorbs moisture, which could potentially lower the longevity and efficiency of the printed item.

Furthermore, recycling these materials presents another set of challenges. While ABS plastic is capable of being recycled, it takes much larger amounts of energy to recycle than it does to produce from raw materials. As for nylon, although biodegradable under industrial conditions, it often ends up in landfills where those specific circumstances aren’t met.

Learn more:
Want.Net Technical Team

Want.Net Technical Team

The Want.Net Technical Team has diverse members with extensive education and training in CNC machining. They prioritize precision, efficiency, and innovation to provide high-quality manufacturing solutions globally.

Push Your Order into Production Today!

Table of Contents


You’re one step from the  factory-direct price of part manufacturing services.